For a French medical or paramedical practice, the lawful basis for phone calls depends on what the call is for. The CNIL’s reference framework for medical and paramedical practices lists legitimate interest for appointment scheduling, while patient records and reimbursement transmission rest on a legal obligation. Recording a call is a separate processing operation with its own basis, its own notice and its own retention limit. When an outside tele-secretary answers the calls, the practice remains the data controller and needs a written processing contract. This article sets out each case in turn.
Key Takeaways
- Appointment scheduling relies on legitimate interest according to the CNIL reference framework for medical practices. Keeping the medical record and transmitting claims to the health insurance rely on a legal obligation.
- Recording a call needs its own purpose, its own basis and an information message at the start of the call.
- A practice that outsources its phone line stays the controller and must sign a processing contract under Article 28 of the GDPR.
- Collect only what the appointment requires: a name, a date of birth, a phone number and the reason for the visit at the level needed to schedule.
- The unsolicited-calling rules that changed in 2026 concern commercial canvassing. They do not govern calls between a practice and its own patients.
Table of Contents
- What “lawful basis” means for a phone call
- Which basis applies to which call
- Recording a call: a separate decision
- When an outside tele-secretary answers the phone
- Retention and security of call data
- What the 2026 rules on unsolicited calls do and do not change
- Perspective
- How ClicFone fits into this framework
- FAQ
- Sources
What “lawful basis” means for a phone call
The GDPR (Regulation (EU) 2016/679) requires every processing of personal data to rest on one of six lawful bases, such as consent, contract, legal obligation or legitimate interest. A phone call is a processing operation as soon as a name, a number, a reason for consultation or a time slot is noted. A call that reveals that someone sees a given specialist can already say something about their health. The CNIL and CNOM practical guide gives the example of a cardiologist: simply knowing about the consultation can indicate a patient’s state of health.
This is why the basis must be chosen and documented before the call is handled, not afterwards. The practice records it in its processing register, along with the purpose, the categories of data, the recipients and the retention period.
Which basis applies to which call
The CNIL reference framework for medical and paramedical practices distinguishes the purposes of a practice. The table summarizes what it states for the processing that touches phone calls.
| Processing | Lawful basis according to the CNIL framework | |
|---|---|---|
| Appointment scheduling | Legitimate interest | |
| Medical record and care file | Legal obligation | |
| Transmission to the health insurance | Legal obligation | |
| Telemedicine (art. L. | ||
| 6316-1 of the Public Health Code) | Legitimate interest | Telecare (art. L. |
Source: CNIL, reference framework for medical and paramedical practices.
Appointment calls and reminders
A patient who calls to book, move or cancel an appointment expects the practice to note the request and the contact details. Legitimate interest is the basis the CNIL lists for this. In practice, this means three habits:
- Tell patients, in the practice’s information notice, that their data is used to manage appointments.
- Allow patients to object simply.
- Keep the data collected to what scheduling needs.
For reminders sent by text, a separate checklist applies, covered in our guide to GDPR-compliant text appointment reminders.
Calls that feed the medical record
When a call leads to information entering the patient record, for example a symptom reported to the practice, the record itself rests on a legal obligation. The reasoning is different from scheduling: the practitioner must keep a record, so the patient’s consent is not what makes it lawful.
What a call should collect
The CNIL/CNOM guide considers it legitimate to collect, for care: surname, first name, date of birth, address and phone number. The social security number is justified only to issue claim forms and transmit them electronically. Health data (history, diagnoses, treatments, test results) belongs in the record. Lifestyle information is collected only with the patient’s agreement and when necessary for diagnosis and care. A phone call for an appointment therefore does not need the social security number or a detailed history.

Recording a call: a separate decision
A practice does not record calls by default. If it chooses to, the recording is a new processing with its own purpose. Three CNIL requirements frame it.
Information at the time of the call. According to CNIL Direct, each caller must be told, when the call starts, the purpose of the recording or listening, the recipients, their right to object and their right of access to the recordings. A message at the start of the call can do this, completed by a contractual mention or a link to a website.
A basis that matches the purpose. The CNIL accepts recording to prove that a contract was formed on the basis of the contract (Article 6.1.b of the GDPR), under conditions set out in its guidance on evidence of contract formation: the recording must be necessary, meaning no other proof such as a written confirmation is possible; only the part of the conversation about concluding the contract is recorded; and retention is limited to the limitation period, five years under ordinary law. For a medical practice, that framework fits poorly with clinical conversations, so the purpose must be defined narrowly and documented before any recording starts.
Access and traceability. The same CNIL page requires the information to include the controller’s identity, the purpose, the legal basis, the recipients, the retention period, the right to object, the rights of access and rectification, and the possibility of lodging a complaint with the CNIL. Access to recordings is limited to authorized people, with permissions and IT traceability.
Our detailed pages cover secure call recording in French clinics and encrypted call recording in healthcare.

When an outside tele-secretary answers the phone
Outsourcing the line does not outsource the responsibility. According to the CNIL/CNOM guide, the practice remains the controller of the identification and health data collected when appointments are made, even if a third party handles it. The practice must then:
- enter the processing in its register;
- limit access to the planning and secure its content;
- notify the CNIL in the event of a data breach;
- formalize the relationship with a processing contract.
The contract is required by Article 28 of the GDPR. The controller may only use processors offering sufficient guarantees. The contract defines the subject and duration of the processing, its nature and purposes, the type of data and the categories of people concerned. Data is returned or deleted at the end of the service unless the law requires retention. The CNIL/CNOM guide adds the expected clauses: processing on instruction, staff confidentiality, security, prior written authorization for sub-processors, cooperation, return or deletion of data, and audits.
A practical reading for a practice: before signing with any tele-secretarial provider, check that the contract contains each of these clauses. Our guide to the medical answering service processing agreement goes through them.
Retention and security of call data
The CNIL reference framework allows practice management data to be kept for 20 years from the last care episode: five years in the active database from the last intervention on the file, then 15 years in an archive on a separate medium with equivalent security. Duplicates of electronic claim forms are kept for three months under Article R. 161-47 of the Social Security Code. These periods concern management and care data. A call recording kept as proof follows its own, shorter limit, as seen above.
The CNIL/CNOM guide also recommends limiting the information collected for appointments, keeping a register, restricting access and securing the planning. It states that instant messaging must be used with great care and securely. Our page on call log retention in France details how these periods apply to logs.
What the 2026 rules on unsolicited calls do and do not change
Since 11 August 2026, according to the CNIL’s page on telephone canvassing, commercial canvassing of consumers by phone requires prior consent: free, specific, informed and unambiguous, given by a positive action such as an unticked box. Accepting terms of use is not enough. The rule comes from Article L. 223-1 of the Consumer Code, introduced by the law of 30 June 2025. The CNIL lists three exceptions, including calls about an ongoing contract and related to its purpose.
This framework targets sales prospecting. A practice calling a patient to confirm or move an appointment is administering care, under the bases described above, not canvassing. Practices should still avoid using appointment data to promote unrelated services.
Perspective
After more than 15 years of handling medical calls, we see the same pattern: compliance questions arise less at the moment of the call than in the paperwork around it. Who is the controller? Is there a signed contract? Has the caller been informed?
Our approach combines trained human tele-secretaries with AI support, and it is built around medical confidentiality. A practice that externalizes its phone line gains a consistent answer at any time of day, and keeps control of its obligations when the contract, the register entry and the access rules are in place from the start.
We think the telephone is an intelligent filter: it qualifies the request, collects only what scheduling needs and passes the rest to the practitioner. That discipline is both better care organization and better data protection.
Rudolph Thierry
How ClicFone fits into this framework
ClicFone provides outsourced medical and paramedical telephone answering: appointment scheduling, synchronization with Doctolib, LibreRDV, Maiia and CalenDoc, coordination of patient calls and handling of medical emergencies, with trained human operators and AI support in line with confidentiality standards. Offers are flexible and carry no commitment. Practices can see how remote call handling works or read about medical phone triage.

FAQ
Do we need patient consent to take appointment calls?
Not as the lawful basis. The CNIL framework lists legitimate interest for appointment scheduling. The practice still informs patients and lets them object easily.
Can a practice record calls with patients?
Only for a defined purpose, with a suitable basis and an information message at the start of the call. The CNIL requires callers to be told the purpose, the recipients, the right to object and the right of access. Retention must be limited to what that purpose justifies.
Who is responsible for data when a tele-secretary answers?
The practice remains the controller. The tele-secretarial provider acts as processor under a written contract that meets Article 28 of the GDPR.
Do the new telephone canvassing rules apply to appointment reminders?
They concern commercial prospecting of consumers, which has required prior consent since 11 August 2026. Appointment administration for existing patients is a different purpose.
Sources
- CNIL, reference framework for medical and paramedical practices
- CNIL and CNOM, practical guide to personal data protection (June 2018)
- CNIL Direct, informing callers about recording or listening
- CNIL, recording calls to prove contract formation
- Regulation (EU) 2016/679 on EUR-Lex
- CNIL, commercial telephone canvassing rules