For a French medical or paramedical practice, the question is rarely email or SMS alone. Email carries the full information and a management link, while SMS reaches the patient close to the appointment. Neither channel handles what happens next: a patient who wants to move, cancel or ask a question will usually pick up the phone. A reminder strategy works best when both written channels are paired with a well-staffed telephone line, which is where a medical tele-secretary service such as ClicFone’s fits.
This article compares the two channels on the criteria that matter to a general practitioner, a specialist, a paramedical professional or a health center team: effect on attendance, cost, timing, confidentiality and message content.
Key Takeaways
- Electronic reminders raise attendance: a 2016 systematic review found 67% attendance with notifications against 54% without, and multiple reminders worked better than a single one.
- SMS is cheap and widely effective, but it should be limited to practical information (date, time, documents) and never carry personalized medical advice.
- Email suits detailed information and a link to manage the appointment, but it does not guarantee confidentiality of medical data.
- Each reminder generates replies, cancellations and rescheduling requests. Those calls need to be answered, or the benefit of the reminder is lost.
Table of Contents
- Email and SMS Reminders Compared at a Glance
- What the Evidence Says About Attendance
- Email Reminders: Strengths and Limits in a Medical Setting
- SMS Reminders: Strengths and Limits
- When to Use Each Channel
- Message Content: What to Write and What to Avoid
- What Happens After the Reminder
- Choosing a Reminder Setup: Criteria for a Practice
- Promo: A Telephone Line That Completes the Reminder Sequence
- Our Perspective
- FAQ
- Sources
Email and SMS Reminders Compared at a Glance
The two channels do not do the same job. The table below summarizes how they differ for a practice working in France.
| Criterion | SMS | |
|---|---|---|
| Best use | Full appointment details, preparation instructions, management link | Short, close-in reminder with date, time and place |
| Typical timing in French booking platforms | 7 days and 1 day before | 48 hours, then 2 hours before |
| Cost per message | Very low | Low, but higher than email |
| Confidentiality | Standard email does not guarantee it | No encryption, readable by anyone with access to the phone |
| Traceability | Good | Limited proof of reading |
| Risk of going unanswered | A reply can wait if the practitioner is unavailable | Concise format prompts a quick reaction |
| Suitable for medical advice | No, unless through secure messaging | No |
The rest of the article explains each line of this table and what it means for daily organization.
What the Evidence Says About Attendance
The most useful figures come from systematic reviews, which pool many studies instead of relying on a single clinic.
A review published in BMJ Open in 2016 covered 21 studies, with 8,345 notified patients and 7,731 patients who were not notified. Patients who received electronic notifications were 23% more likely to attend (67% against 54%) and 25% less likely to miss an appointment (15% against 21%). The same review found that multiple notifications were more effective than a single one. For a practice, this supports a sequence of reminders rather than a lone message the day before.

Other work looks at SMS specifically. A 2023 review reported that 15 studies found a significant reduction in missed appointments with SMS, against 4 studies with no effect, with an overall positive effect. In an outpatient psychiatry clinic, SMS raised attendance from 72% to 80%, and the authors described it as an inexpensive method that requires confidentiality safeguards.
A realist review from 2016 adds a point of method: it found no demonstrated difference in effectiveness between reminder technologies such as SMS and telephone calls. The channel therefore matters less than three other factors: that a reminder is sent, that it is repeated at sensible intervals, and that the patient can easily respond.
Email Reminders: Strengths and Limits in a Medical Setting
Email offers room. A message can include the address, the access instructions, the documents to bring, preparation instructions for an examination and a link to confirm or cancel. It also leaves a trace, which is useful for the practice’s records.
The limits are mostly about confidentiality and expectations. The professional liability insurer MACSF notes that email offers speed and traceability but does not guarantee the confidentiality of medical data, that it can remain unanswered when the practitioner is unavailable, and that many patients expect a reply within 48 hours. For a reminder, this has a practical consequence: a patient who replies by email to cancel may wait a day or two for an answer, and the slot stays blocked during that time.
The joint guide from the CNIL (the French data protection authority) and the Cnom (the national medical council) is specific on method. Secure health messaging is possible only between healthcare professionals. For exchanges with patients through standard email, sensitive attachments must be encrypted, transfers must use SFTP or HTTPS, and the password must travel by a different channel such as the telephone or SMS. A reminder that contains only the date, time and place avoids most of this difficulty, because no medical information is exposed.
SMS Reminders: Strengths and Limits
SMS is short, immediate and read on a device that patients carry. That makes it well suited to the close-in reminder, the one that prevents a forgotten appointment.
Cost is a clear advantage over manual calls. A 2011 systematic review of 29 studies estimated the average cost of a reminder at €0.41 per patient: €0.90 for a manual telephone reminder against €0.14 for an SMS or an automated call. That review also reported an average 34% reduction in missed appointments compared with baseline. These are figures from published studies at different periods, and the actual cost of a message depends on the contract with the SMS or booking provider.
The limits concern content. MACSF states that SMS does not guarantee confidentiality, since anyone with access to the phone can read the exchange and the system is not encrypted. It cannot be considered a means of prescription, because it does not meet the conditions of the Code de la santé publique. The practitioner can never be certain that the message was delivered to the right person, read, or left unread by a third party.
The guidance that follows is simple. SMS is appropriate for appointment reminders, general questions about how the practice operates and reminders about documents. For any medical problem, the better response is to offer a phone call.

When to Use Each Channel
The French booking platforms already apply a sequence that practices can use as a reference. On its practitioner help pages, Doctolib describes email reminders at 7 days and 1 day before, a first SMS or push notification 48 hours before (24 hours when the appointment was booked less than 7 days ahead), and a second reminder 2 hours before. Appointments booked online less than 48 hours ahead receive no reminder email or SMS. The patient-facing help page adds that a confirmation email goes out within ten minutes of booking, and that SMS is sent only when push notifications from the mobile app are not activated.
This structure shows a sensible division of labor:
- Email, one week and one day before: complete information, preparation instructions, link to manage the appointment.
- SMS or push, 48 hours then 2 hours before: short proximity reminders.
- Telephone: anything that needs a conversation, such as a patient with a doubt about whether to come, a rescheduling request, or a case that may be urgent.
Practices that do not use a booking platform, or that handle part of their bookings by phone, need to reproduce this sequence on their own. Short appointments booked less than 48 hours ahead fall outside the automatic reminders on some platforms, which is a gap to cover deliberately, for instance with a call.
Message Content: What to Write and What to Avoid
A reminder is a logistical message. A short checklist keeps it within what the channel can safely carry:
- Practice name, date, time and address. Nothing else is needed for the close-in reminder.
- A simple way to respond. A phone number answered during opening hours, or a management link in the email.
- Documents to bring. Reminders about documents are among the uses MACSF considers appropriate for SMS.
- No diagnosis, result or treatment information. The practitioner cannot control who reads an SMS, so personalized medical content stays out of it.
- No more data than necessary. The CNIL and Cnom guide asks practices to limit data to what is necessary, keep a register of processing activities, secure the data and notify the CNIL of breaches presenting a risk.
For a deeper look at the compliance side of text messages, ClicFone has published a guide to GDPR-compliant text appointment reminders. The wording of reminder phone calls is covered in a separate resource on reminder call script content.
What Happens After the Reminder
A reminder produces a reaction. Some patients confirm, some ask to move the appointment, and some cancel. The channel used for the reminder changes how those reactions arrive.
The 2016 realist review observed that telephone reminders increase cancellations, from 17-26% against 8-12% without a reminder, and that this made it possible to reallocate 27% to 40% of the freed slots. SMS reminders did not increase cancellations in the same review. The practical reading is that a reminder is most valuable when the practice can act on a cancellation: a slot freed 48 hours ahead can be offered to another patient, while a slot freed 10 minutes ahead usually cannot. Practices that want to organize this can read about reallocating freed appointment slots and about managing medical appointment cancellations and a waitlist for freed slots.
In a busy practice, the difficulty is that these responses arrive while the practitioner is with a patient. A reminder campaign can increase the number of incoming calls in the hours that follow, particularly the morning after a batch of messages. If the line is busy or unanswered, the patient may simply not come, and the reminder has achieved nothing. The principles for keeping a line reachable are described in a guide on improving doctor phone availability, and the specific context of paramedical practices is covered in a piece on reducing no-shows in paramedical clinics.
Choosing a Reminder Setup: Criteria for a Practice
A practice can decide using five questions.
- Who are the patients? Older patients may respond better to a call or a letter, while younger patients typically respond to SMS or push notifications. The study in psychiatric outpatients found that letters and SMS both improved attendance, while calls produced no significant effect on attendance.
- How are appointments booked? Online booking platforms handle the automatic sequence. Phone bookings need their own process.
- What is the cost per message? SMS is inexpensive compared with manual calls, and push notifications can replace SMS where the patient has activated the app, which avoids the cost of the text message.
- What is the risk to confidentiality? The content decides. A date and a time are logistical; anything related to health is not for SMS or standard email.
- Who handles the reactions? The most overlooked question. A sequence of reminders is complete only when someone answers, reschedules and reuses the freed slot.
For teams in a health center, one additional point applies: with several practitioners and shared agendas, a rescheduling request must reach the right calendar. A guide to medical appointment sync software describes what to look for, and a note on preventing double bookings with a live calendar check addresses the risk when several people book into the same agenda.
Promo: A Telephone Line That Completes the Reminder Sequence
ClicFone provides outsourced medical and paramedical telephone answering: qualified human tele-secretaries, supported by AI for round-the-clock coverage, who handle appointment scheduling, coordinate patient calls and manage medical emergencies. The service synchronizes with Doctolib, LibreRDV, Maiia and CalenDoc, so that a rescheduling request prompted by an email or an SMS reminder is recorded in the practice’s calendar. Medical confidentiality is part of the service’s design, and the offers are flexible, with no commitment.
Practices that want to see how this works in practice can start with the five scheduling rules and one-week pilot plan, or contact the team through the ClicFone website.

Our Perspective
Email and SMS are often presented as rivals, but in a medical practice they answer different needs. Email informs, SMS reminds, and the telephone resolves. The evidence points the same way: multiple reminders outperform a single one, and the channel matters less than the follow-through.
After more than 15 years in medical telephone answering, we consider the telephone as an intelligent filter. A patient who receives a reminder and cannot attend wants to speak to someone, quickly, and to leave with a new appointment. That conversation needs a trained voice that knows the vocabulary of healthcare, understands which calls are urgent and writes the result directly in the agenda.
This is why our tele-secretaries are dedicated human operators trained for the medical sector, supported by AI to keep the line available 24 hours a day. The practitioner keeps control of the message, the content and the confidentiality, and delegates the calls that follow it. Over half of our clients have been with us for more than ten years, which we take as a sign that the organization serves practices well in daily routine.
Rudolph Thierry
FAQ
Is SMS or email better for medical appointment reminders?
Neither is better in every case. SMS suits the short reminder close to the appointment, while email suits the complete information a week or a day before. Published reviews show that electronic reminders increase attendance and that multiple reminders work better than a single one, so a combination is the most reliable approach.
Can a medical practice send reminders by SMS under French rules?
Yes, for logistical content. MACSF considers SMS appropriate for appointment reminders, general questions about the practice and reminders about documents. SMS does not guarantee confidentiality, so it should not carry personalized medical advice, results or prescriptions. The CNIL and Cnom guide also asks practices to limit data to what is necessary.
Do reminders increase cancellations?
Phone reminders do, according to a 2016 realist review, with cancellations of 17-26% against 8-12% without a reminder. SMS reminders did not increase cancellations in the same review. Cancellations are not a loss when the practice can reuse the freed slot, which is why a fast answer on the phone matters.
What should a reminder message contain?
The practice name, date, time and address, plus a clear way to confirm, move or cancel. Documents to bring can be added. Any health information stays out of SMS and standard email, and a phone call is the better channel for a medical question.
Sources
- MACSF: Communiquer avec ses patients par mail, SMS ou téléphone
- Robotham et al., Using digital notifications to improve attendance in clinic (BMJ Open, 2016)
- McLean et al., Appointment reminder systems are effective but not optimal (2016)
- Kunigiri et al., Improving attendance in psychiatric outpatient clinics (2014)
- Werner et al., Behavioural economic interventions to reduce health care appointment non-attendance (2023)
- Hasvold and Wootton, Use of telephone and SMS reminders to improve attendance at hospital appointments (2011)
- Doctolib (practitioners): notifications sent to patients
- Doctolib (patients): confirmation and reminder notifications
- CNIL and Cnom: Guide pratique sur la protection des données personnelles (2025 version)
- CNIL and Cnom: Guide pratique sur la protection des données personnelles (2018)